
EMI Classics - EMI Classics
Johann Sebastian Bach
Release date: 2004-07-13
Audio CD
Classical, Classical Composers, Classical Music, Concerto, Concerto Grosso, Orchestral & Symphonic
1. I: (Allegro)
2. II: Adagio
3. III: Allegro
4. IV: Menuet & Trio
5. I: (Allegro)
6. II: Andante
7. III: Allegro Assai
8. I: Allegro
9. II: Adagio (By George Malcolm)
10. III: Allegro
11. I: Allegro - Iona Brown
12. II: Andante
13. III: Presto




I think with the Brandenbergs, the deciding factor on which set to buy is whether you prefer modern instruments or period instruments. There are probably more great period instrument recordings (Trevor Pinnock and the English Concert is my personal favorite) to choose from than modern instrument recordings, but I think this is the best available modern instrument recording. You pretty much cannot go wrong with anything by Marriner and the ASMF, but this is truly one of their better recordings and has been for a number of years. There may be others out there just as good, but I doubt if you will find any better.
Bach's Brandenburg Concertos, like much of Bach's works, are very modern sounding pieces. That's what makes them so appealing. Although each movement is no more than a few minutes long, the melodies and form of each are well developed and gorgeous.
This recording is especially worth buying because Marriner and the Academy produce a well-balanced and well-played interpretation. The instruments are not period instruments, and I think that that adds to the overall flavor of this recording. Although Boston Baroque offer recordings using period pieces, they don't match the interpretive genius of Neville Marriner.
Overall, this disc is a great buy -- only a few dollars for some of my favorite pieces by Bach. Don't let the low price fool you into believing that that somehow is an indication of quality.